Prospects for Import Substitution in the Russian IT Sector under Sanctions Pressure
Abstract
Since March 2022, the Russian information technology (IT) industry has been operating under unprecedented sanctions pressure, resulting in a profound transformation. The government and private sector entities must address the challenge of facilitating a rapid transition from products sourced from foreign vendors and foreign software to domestically developed alternatives. The objective of this study is twofold: first, to evaluate the potential for import substitution in specific sectors of the Russian IT market, based on an analysis of the progress made in the transition to domestic products and developments; and second, to identify strategies for overcoming the challenges associated with this transition.
The process of import substitution in the Russian IT sector is gaining pace driven by two key factors: the government’s stated objective of achieving technological sovereignty as well as private business’s development needs. However, the timing of the transition will vary significantly depending on the market segment in question. The highest rates of penetration of Russian products are observed in information security segment, reaching up to 80%. The lowest rates of penetration are observed in the segment of mobile operating systems, as well as in process management tools, reaching only 25–35%. In order to achieve the stated goals, it is necessary to maintain the state support measures and, in some segments, to expand them and develop new ones. This should be done with the consideration of the initial experience of market participants in import substitution. It is possible that the government may extend the timeframe for the complete transition to domestic products for the public sector and large state-owned companies, contingent on the progress in overcoming the existing barriers to import substitution. At the same time, the longer-term goals, set to achieve the required level of utilization of Russian IT products, will not be revised in a more conservative direction.
Downloads
References
Anti-Malware.ru, 2022. How painful for Russian companies were the cyberattacks of 2022. Available at: https://www.anti-malware.ru/analytics/Threats_Analysis/Attacks-on-Russian-companies-1st-half-of-2022 (accessed 30.03.2023) (in Russian).
CSR, 2023 (1). Forecast of cybersecurity market development in the Russian Federation for 2023-2027. Available at: https://www.csr.ru/upload/iblock/0da/cl25xkzy12if5l4xs425yi25ezp1a11z.pdf (accessed 12.09.2023) (in Russian).
CSR, 2023 (2). Ekaterina Kvasha: “Russian vendors occupy 70% of the information security market”. Available at: https://www.csr.ru/ru/events/ekaterina-kvasha-rossiyskie-vendory-zanimayut-70-rynka-ib/ (accessed 20.12.2023) (in Russian).
Finmarket, 2023. According to the results of the year, the total turnover of Russian software developers will grow by 24%. Available at: https://www.finmarket.ru/news/6044600?ysclid=lpzt9npsq7919486091 (accessed 14.11.2023) (in Russian).
Gosuslugi, 2023. Small and medium-sized businesses will be able to buy Russian software 50% cheaper. Available at: https://www.gosuslugi.ru/life/details/21_11_25_soft (accessed 10.02.2023) (in Russian).
Interfax, 2023 (1). Shadayev spoke out on the possibility of extending profit tax benefits for IT companies. Available at: https://www.interfax.ru/business/933689 (accessed 28.11.2023) (in Russian).
Interfax, 2023 (2). The head of the Ministry of Finance said that about 100 thousand IT workers left the Russian Federation this year. Available at: https://www.interfax.ru/russia/877771 (accessed 13.07.2023) (in Russian).
INTERFAX-PROZAKUPKI, 2023. The share of domestic products in radio electronics will exceed 20% by the end of 2022. Available at: https://prozakupki.interfax.ru/articles/2647?ysclid=lpodm3s7sz79635844 (accessed 13.11.2023) (in Russian).
K2Tech, 2023 (1). K2Tech survey: Only 13% of companies have a clear plan for import substitution. Available at: https://k2.tech/press_releases/issledovanie-k2tehtolko-u-13-kompanij-est-chetkij-plan-po-importozameshheniyu/ (accessed 03.12.2023) (in Russian).
K2Tech, 2023 (2). Only 13% of companies have a clear import substitution plan. Available at: https://k2.tech/press_releases/issledovanie-k2tehtolko-u-13-kompanij-est-chetkij-plan-po-importozameshheniyu/ (accessed 15.12.2023) (in Russian).
Kommersant, 2022 (1). Treasury goes RISC. Available at: https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/5193413 (accessed 14.07.2023) (in Russian).
Kommersant, 2022 (2). State support has been added to software. Available at: https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/5735777?ysclid=lt1piuedvn773922569 (accessed 03.08.2023) (in Russian).
Kommersant, 2023 (1). EU enacts 11th package of anti-Russian sanctions. Available at: https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/6067229?query=IT (accessed 01.08.2023) (in Russian).
Kommersant, 2023 (2). On the state border. Export revenue of Russian IT companies fell by 17%. Available at: https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/5844459 (accessed 12.07.2023) (in Russian).
Kommersant, 2023 (3). To a small circle of friends. Russian industrial software is looking for foreign sales markets. Available at: https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/6083548?from=doc_vrez (accessed 01.08.2023) (in Russian).
Order of the Ministry of Digital Development, Communications and Mass Media of the Russian Federation No. 21 of 18 January 2023, “On Approval of the Methodological Recommendations on the Transition to the Use of Russian Software, Including on Significant Objects of the Critical Information Infrastructure of the Russian Federation, and on the Implementation of Measures Aimed at Accelerated Transition of Public Authorities and Organizations to the Use of Russian Software in The Russian Federation” (in Russian).
Presidential Decree No. 166 of 30 March 2022, “On Measures to Ensure Technological Independence and Security of the Critical Information Infrastructure of the Russian Federation” (in Russian).
Russian Government, 2022. The roadmaps “New Industrial Software” and “New System-wide Software” Approved. Available at: http://government.ru/news/47353/ (accessed 10.09.2023) (in Russian).
RUSSOFT, 2022. Russian software industry. 19th annual survey. Available at: https://russoft.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/survey2022.pdf (accessed 05.06.2023) (in Russian).
RUSSOFT, 2023. RUSSOFT Summary of Russian software exports. Available at: https://russoft.org/analytics/kratkij-obzor-russoft-eksporta-rossijskogo-programmnogo-obespecheniya/ (accessed 23.12.2023) (in Russian).
Softline, 2023 (1). Investor presentation: growth story in the present, past and future. Available at: https://softline.ru/investor-relations/ipo-materials/ (accessed 01.12.2023) (in Russian).
Softline, 2023 (2). Prospectus of issue of ordinary shares of PJSC Softline. Available at: https://softline.ru/uploads/files/Проспект.pdf (accessed 08.09.2023) (in Russian).
Strategy Partners, 2023 (1). Russian infrastructure software market and its development prospects. Available at: https://strategy.ru/research/research/47 (accessed 15.12.2023) (in Russian).
Strategy Partners, 2023 (2). Russian infrastructure software market and its development prospects. Available at: https://strategy.ru/research/research/47 (accessed 16.12.2023) (in Russian).
TAdviser, 2024. Software exports from Russia: Russia is one of the largest software exporters in the world. Available at: https://www.tadviser.ru/ (accessed 09.02.2024) (in Russian).
TASS, 2022. MinTsifry: losses of international IT companies after leaving the Russian Federation amounted to 650-700 billion rubles. Available at: https://tass.ru/ekonomika/16639999?ysclid=lpzmyrlhl5456983847 (accessed 19.09.2023) (in Russian).
Vedomosti, 2023 (1). The cost of software in retail and corporate sales increased by 10-40%. Available at: https://www.vedomosti.ru/technology/articles/2023/11/28/1008040-stoimost-softa-v-roznichnih-korporativnih-prodazhah-virosla?ysclid=lpzo9m6vjz523377865 (accessed 12.12.2023) (in Russian).
Vedomosti, 2023 (2). Half of Russian companies failed to renew licenses for foreign software. Available at: https://www.vedomosti.ru/technology/articles/2023/05/25/976746-polovina-rossiiskih-kompanii-ne-smogla-prodlit-litsenzii-na-inostrannii-soft?ysclid=lpzndfey3t873754415 (accessed 12.08.2023) (in Russian).
Vedomosti, 2023 (3). Russia will create a consortium to ensure technological independence of the oil and gas industry. Available at: https://www.vedomosti.ru/press_releases/2023/06/15/v-rossii-sozdadut-konsortsium-dlya-obespecheniya-tehnologicheskoi-nezavisimosti-neftegazovoi-otrasli?ysclid=lpqyshjcqo172793894 (accessed 30.10.2023) (in Russian).
Vedomosti, 2023 (4). MinTsifry has created a unified database of all business needs in software. Available at: https://www.vedomosti.ru/technology/articles/2023/07/10/984460-mintsifri-sozdalo-edinuyu-bazu (accessed 14.11.2023) (in Russian).
1.jpg)
